Mediation vs arbitration: what is the difference?
Both are ways to settle a dispute without a trial, but they work very differently. Mediation helps you reach a deal. Arbitration is a decision by a neutral person.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 4 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
Two ways to settle without a trial
A lawsuit is not the only way to resolve a dispute. Two common alternatives, often grouped as alternative dispute resolution, are mediation and arbitration. They sound alike, and people mix them up. The key difference is who makes the decision.
Mediation: you decide
In mediation, a neutral person called a mediator helps both sides talk and look for a deal. The mediator does not decide who is right and cannot force anyone to agree. If you reach a deal, you sign a written agreement. If you do not, you are free to go on to court.
- You usually meet at a set time, in person or by video, and often spend part of it in separate rooms.
- What is said in mediation is usually kept private, though rules differ by state.
- Many courts offer mediation, sometimes at no charge or a low cost, especially in small claims. Ask the clerk.
Arbitration: someone else decides
In arbitration, a neutral person called an arbitrator, or a panel, hears both sides and makes a decision, called an award. It is like a private trial, usually less formal and often faster than court. There is no jury.
- Binding arbitration
- The decision is final. You can almost never take it to a judge, except for narrow reasons such as fraud or bias.
- Non-binding arbitration
- The arbitrator gives a decision, but either side can reject it and go to court.
- Arbitration clause
- Contract language that requires disputes to go to arbitration. See arbitration clauses.
- Mediator
- A neutral helper who cannot decide your case.
Side by side
| Mediation | Arbitration | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | You and the other side, together | The arbitrator |
| Is the result forced on you | No, only if you agree | Yes if binding. Not if non-binding. |
| Can you still go to court | Yes, if no deal is reached | Binding: very rarely. Non-binding: yes. |
| How formal | Informal conversation | More like a hearing, with evidence |
| Cost | Often lower. Court programs may cost little or nothing. | Varies. Private arbitration can charge fees for the arbitrator and administration. |
| How long | Often one session | Often shorter than court, but depends on the case |
| Good for | Disputes where a deal is possible | Disputes where you want a decision without a court trial, or a contract requires it |
How you end up in one
- Court-ordered or court-offered: many courts refer cases to mediation, especially small claims. It may be a step before the hearing.
- By agreement: both sides can choose either one at any point, even after filing.
- By contract: an agreement you signed earlier, such as a job or service contract, may require arbitration. Read can you sue despite an arbitration clause.
Before you start either, think about what you want. Read should you sue if you are still deciding.
Which fits you
Questions to ask first
0 of 7 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Quick check
A neutral person hears both sides and issues a final decision you cannot appeal. What is this?
Questions
Is mediation required before small claims court?
It depends on the court. Some courts require or strongly encourage mediation, and others offer it on the day of the hearing. Check your court's page or ask the clerk.
Can I go to court if mediation fails?
Yes. A mediator cannot force an agreement, so if you do not reach one you can continue with your case. Anything you sign in mediation, though, is binding.
Is arbitration cheaper than court?
Sometimes, but not always. Private arbitration can charge fees for the arbitrator and the provider. Ask who pays and how much before you agree.
What does binding mean?
A binding decision is final. You cannot ask a judge to hear the case again, except in narrow situations. A non-binding decision can be rejected by either side.
Do I need a lawyer for mediation or arbitration?
Not required in most. Many people attend mediation on their own. For arbitration, rules differ, so ask your law firm if you are unsure how to prepare.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Costs and optionsSettlement offers explained: how they work and what to do
A settlement ends a dispute by agreement instead of a judge's ruling. Learn how offers and counteroffers work, why to put the deal in writing, and what a federal Rule 68 offer is.
5 min readRead
Costs and optionsArbitration clause: can you still sue?
Many contracts and job agreements say disputes go to arbitration, not court. Learn how to find the clause, what it may allow, and what to ask before you file.
5 min readRead
Small claimsSmall claims mediation: how court mediation works and what if it fails
Many small claims courts offer mediation, a private conversation with a neutral helper before the hearing. Here is how a session runs, what signing means and what happens if you do not agree.
5 min readRead