Small claims mediation: how court mediation works and what if it fails
Many small claims courts offer mediation, a private conversation with a neutral helper before the hearing. Here is how a session runs, what signing means and what happens if you do not agree.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 5 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
What mediation is
Mediation is a meeting where a neutral person, the mediator, helps the two sides try to reach their own agreement. The mediator does not decide who is right and cannot force a deal. You stay in control of the result.
Many small claims courts have mediation programs, run by court staff or trained volunteers, and some are free. Others point you to a community dispute center. Programs differ a lot, so ask your court's clerk or check its website, and see your state under small claims.
How you end up in mediation
- The court offers it on hearing day. A clerk or mediator may ask both sides whether they want to talk first.
- The court schedules it ahead. Some courts send a notice with a mediation date.
- Either side asks for it. You can ask the clerk whether mediation is available.
- Some courts require it, and others make it voluntary. Check your notice.
How a session runs
Step 1: Introductions
The mediator explains the process and the ground rules, such as taking turns and keeping what is said private. Ask what confidentiality means in your program.
Step 2: Each side tells its story
You each describe what happened and what you want, without interruptions.
Step 3: Talking it through
The mediator asks questions, looks for common ground and may meet with each side alone for a few minutes.
Step 4: Making offers
You and the other side trade ideas. Money is common, but so are other terms, like a payment plan or a repair.
Step 5: Deciding
If you both agree, the terms are written down. If not, you can walk away.
Sessions are often short. Bring the same papers you would bring to a hearing. See what to bring. Think in advance about the lowest amount you would accept and what else would matter to you, and keep it to yourself until you decide.
Signing an agreement
If you reach a deal, it is usually written down and both sides sign. A signed agreement can be a binding promise, and in many courts it is filed with the court and may become a court order. Rules differ.
Before you sign
0 of 8 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
What if mediation does not work
Not every session ends in a deal, and that is fine. If you do not agree, your case usually goes back to the judge, either that day or on a later date. What you said during mediation is often kept private and not used at the hearing. Ask the mediator how it works in your program.
- Keep your evidence ready, since the hearing may follow right away.
- Write down any offers you were glad to accept, to think about later.
- If a deal is signed but not followed, ask the clerk what steps you can take. See collect a judgment.
Quick check
At mediation, who decides the outcome?
Questions
Is small claims mediation free?
Often it is free or low cost when run by the court, but programs differ. Ask the clerk whether your court's mediation has a fee and who runs it.
Do I have to agree to mediation?
Some courts require you to try it, and many make it optional. Check your hearing notice, and ask the clerk if you are not sure.
Is what I say in mediation private?
In most programs, what is said in mediation is kept confidential and is not used at the hearing, but rules differ. Ask the mediator to explain the rules before you start.
Is a mediated agreement binding?
A signed agreement is a promise, and in many courts it can be entered as a court order. Read it closely before signing, and ask your law firm if you are unsure.
What if the other side does not follow the agreement?
Tell the clerk. Depending on your court, the agreement may be enforceable like a judgment, or you may need to ask the court to go back to the hearing. Rules vary.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Small claims8 min readRead the guideSmall claims court: how to file, step by step
What small claims court is, what to gather before you file, how filing works, what to expect at the hearing and what comes after.
If you're suedHow to settle a lawsuit yourself: negotiating, agreements and dismissal papers
Most lawsuits end in a settlement, not a trial. Learn how to negotiate on your own, put the deal in writing, end the case with the court, and check the terms before signing.
6 min readRead
Small claimsWhat happens at a small claims hearing: from check-in to decision
A walk through hearing day: arriving, checking in, waiting for your case to be called, how the judge runs the hearing, and when you learn the decision.
5 min readRead