Settlement offers explained: how they work and what to do
A settlement ends a dispute by agreement instead of a judge's ruling. Learn how offers and counteroffers work, why to put the deal in writing, and what a federal Rule 68 offer is.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 5 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
What a settlement is
A settlement is an agreement that ends a dispute. One side usually pays money, does something or stops doing something, and in return the other side gives up their claim. Most disputes end this way, sometimes before a case is filed and sometimes after it has started.
A settlement is a choice. You are not required to accept an offer, and the other side is not required to make one. This is general information, not legal advice. Ask your law firm about your own case before you agree to anything. If you are still deciding whether to file at all, read should you sue, and for a neutral helper see mediation vs arbitration.
How offers and counteroffers work
Step 1: An offer is made
One side proposes terms, such as an amount to be paid and by when. It may come in a letter, an email, a call or at a hearing.
Step 2: You think it over
Do not feel pressed to answer on the spot. Ask how long the offer stays open, and ask for it in writing if it was not.
Step 3: You accept, reject or counter
A counteroffer is a new proposal. It usually ends the first offer, so if you might want the original terms, say so before you counter.
Step 4: Both sides agree on every term
A deal exists only when both sides clearly agree on the same terms.
Step 5: You put it in writing and sign
The agreement should be written, signed and dated. See the next section.
Put it in writing
A verbal promise is hard to prove later. If you reach a deal, write down the terms and have both sides sign. If a lawsuit is already filed, the court usually has to be told, often by a dismissal or a stipulation, so the case is not left open.
- Who is paying or doing something, with full names.
- What exactly, including the amount and how it will be paid.
- When, with dates, and what happens if a payment is missed.
- What is released: which claims end, and whether anyone admits fault.
- What happens to the case, such as dismissal, and who pays court costs.
- Signatures and dates of everyone involved.
Federal Rule 68 offers of judgment
In federal court, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 68 lets a party that is being sued make a formal offer to allow a judgment against them on stated terms. In plain words, here is how it works.
- Step 1: The defending party serves a written offer, at least 14 days before the trial date.
- Step 2: The other side has 14 days to accept in writing. If they accept, either side can file the offer and acceptance, and the clerk enters judgment.
- Step 3: If it is not accepted in that time, it is considered withdrawn. It cannot be used as proof of liability.
- Step 4: If you reject it and the judgment you later get is not more favorable than the offer, you must pay the costs the other side incurred after the offer was made.
This is the rule's main risk. It shifts costs, not usually your own money for the claim itself. Whether Rule 68 costs include attorney's fees can depend on the law behind the claim. If you receive one, take it seriously and read it twice. See the rule on uscourts.gov and ask your law firm about your options. For costs in general, read court costs you can recover.
Weighing an offer
Before you answer an offer
0 of 7 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Quick check
You get a settlement offer and send a counteroffer. What usually happens to the first offer?
Questions
Do I have to accept a settlement offer?
No. A settlement is voluntary for both sides. You can accept, reject or make a counteroffer. Think about the evidence, cost and risk, and ask your law firm about your own case.
Does a settlement have to be in writing?
Some oral agreements can be enforced, but proving one is hard. Put the terms in writing and have everyone sign, so there is no dispute later about what was agreed.
What is a Rule 68 offer?
It is a formal federal court offer in which a defending party offers to let judgment be entered on stated terms. If you reject it and do worse at the end, you may have to pay later costs.
Can I change my mind after accepting?
Usually not. Once both sides agree and it is signed, it is a binding agreement. That is why you should read every term before you accept.
What happens to my lawsuit if we settle?
Usually the case is dismissed, by a filing that tells the court it is resolved. The agreement should say who will file it and when, and who pays court costs.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
If you're suedHow to settle a lawsuit yourself: negotiating, agreements and dismissal papers
Most lawsuits end in a settlement, not a trial. Learn how to negotiate on your own, put the deal in writing, end the case with the court, and check the terms before signing.
6 min readRead
Costs and optionsMediation vs arbitration: what is the difference?
Both are ways to settle a dispute without a trial, but they work very differently. Mediation helps you reach a deal. Arbitration is a decision by a neutral person.
4 min readRead
Costs and optionsShould you sue? A plain guide to deciding
Before you file, weigh your evidence, the amount at stake, whether the other side can pay, the time limit and the alternatives. A checklist and quiz help you decide.
5 min readRead