Should you sue? A plain guide to deciding
Before you file, weigh your evidence, the amount at stake, whether the other side can pay, the time limit and the alternatives. A checklist and quiz help you decide.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 5 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
Why think before you file
Going to court can be the right move. It can also cost more in time, stress and money than you get back. A short, honest review before you file helps you choose on purpose. This is general information, not legal advice. For your own situation, ask your law firm.
1. How strong is your evidence
A judge decides on proof, not on what is fair. Ask yourself what you can show, not what you know to be true.
- Paper: contracts, invoices, receipts, texts, emails, photos, pay records.
- People: someone who saw or heard what happened and would come to court.
- Dates: a timeline you can back up.
- Gaps: anything you cannot prove, or that the other side will dispute.
If your case rests on your word against theirs with nothing else, it is harder. It is not impossible, but be realistic.
2. The amount against the effort
Count what a win would be worth, then subtract what it takes: filing and service costs, time off work, hours of preparation, and the chance of losing. Small claims courts exist so smaller disputes are worth bringing, and they are built for people without lawyers. See the small claims guide and your state's page under small claims.
Also check your court's limit. If your claim is larger than the small claims limit, you can sometimes give up the excess to stay there, or file in a different court. The small claims limits tool shows where to look.
3. Can the other side pay
A judgment is a court's decision that someone owes you. It is not money in your hand. If the other side has no job, no bank account and no property, collecting can be slow or may not work at all. If they are a business with assets, or an employer with payroll, it can be easier.
Before suing, learn what you can about whether they are still in business, whether they have a steady job, and whether they own property. Read about collecting a judgment first so you know the next steps.
4. Time limits
Every kind of claim has a deadline to file, called a statute of limitations. The length depends on the state and on the type of claim, and some claims, such as certain workplace claims, have much shorter windows. If you wait too long, the court can refuse the case no matter how strong it is. Read about statutes of limitations and use the deadline calculator as a starting point.
5. Alternatives to suing
| Option | What it is | Good when |
|---|---|---|
| Demand letter | A written request for payment or action with a deadline, see the demand letter guide | You have not yet told them in writing what you want |
| Negotiation | Talking or writing back and forth to reach a deal | Both sides want to avoid court |
| Mediation | A neutral person helps you both find a deal, see mediation vs arbitration | Talks stalled but a deal is possible |
| Complaint to an agency | A report to a government office that handles your issue | Your issue is regulated, such as certain consumer or workplace matters |
| Walk away | Accept the loss and move on | Cost and effort clearly outweigh the amount |
Often a demand letter comes first, and courts like to see that you tried. If an offer arrives, read settlement offers explained.
Check yourself
Should I sue? Run through it
0 of 8 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Quick check
You have a strong case, but the person you would sue has no job and no property. What is the main concern?
Questions
How do I know if my case is strong enough?
Look at what you can prove, not only what happened. Papers, messages, photos and witnesses make a case stronger. A law firm can look at your own facts, so ask yours if you are unsure.
Is a demand letter required before suing?
Not always, but many courts like to see you tried, and some claims require notice first. A demand letter also gives the other side a chance to settle. See the demand letter guide.
What if I wait too long?
The court can refuse your case once the time limit has passed, however strong it is. The limit varies by state and claim type, so check early.
Can I sue if I cannot afford the fees?
Often you can ask the court to waive or reduce fees. Rules differ by state, and federal courts have their own application. See the fee waiver guide.
Do I have to sue if the other side ignores my letter?
No. You can choose to let it go. If you do file, keep the letter and proof you sent it, since it shows you tried to settle first.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Starting a case7 min readRead the guideHow to sue someone: a plain-English guide
How a lawsuit starts, how to pick the right court, how to sue a business by its legal name, and what happens after you file, in plain words.
Before you sue3 min readRead the guideStatute of limitations basics: the deadline to file a lawsuit
What the deadline to sue is, why it differs by kind of claim, when the clock starts, what can pause it and how to find the one that applies.
Before you sue4 min readRead the guideHow to write a demand letter, with an outline to follow
What a demand letter is, why it often settles a dispute before court, what to put in it, how to send it, and what to do if there is no reply.