Small claims

Small claims counterclaim: what to do when the other side sues you back

A counterclaim is your own claim against the person who sued you, filed in the same case. Here is how counterclaims work, why deadlines differ by state and what limits apply.

By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 5 min read

A person at a dining table reading a court summons with a pen in hand, with a laptop open to a blank form.

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.

What a counterclaim is

When someone sues you in small claims, you are the defendant. If you believe the other person owes you money for the same dispute, you may be able to make your own claim, called a counterclaim, in that same case. The judge can then hear both sides' claims together.

Plaintiff
The person who filed the case.
Defendant
The person who was sued.
Counterclaim
A claim by the defendant against the plaintiff, in the same case.
Setoff
A reduction of what you owe because the other side owes you money too.

Read your court papers first. If you have been sued and have not yet answered, see respond to a lawsuit and sued in small claims.

When a counterclaim makes sense

  • The claims come from the same dispute. For example, a customer sues a contractor for poor work, and the contractor says the customer never paid the balance.
  • You have proof of what they owe you. Contracts, invoices, photos, messages and receipts.
  • The amount fits your court's limit. Small claims courts have caps, and some apply a separate limit to counterclaims.
  • You would otherwise have to sue later. Raising it now saves a second case, but ask your law firm about whether you must raise it now in your state.

Deadlines and limits differ by state

This is the part to check carefully. States handle counterclaims in different ways.

Things that vary from state to state
QuestionWhat to check
When is the deadline?Some states set a number of days before the hearing, others allow it at the hearing or when you respond. Check your court's rules and the date on your papers.
Is there a form?Many courts have their own counterclaim form. Ask the clerk or find it on the court's website.
Is there a fee?Some courts charge a fee to file a counterclaim, and some do not. Confirm with the clerk.
What is the limit?The court's cap on small claims may apply to your counterclaim. Some states send a larger counterclaim to another court. See small claims limits.
Must you raise it now?In some places, a claim from the same dispute must be raised in the case or it may be lost. Ask your law firm.

Find your state under small claims and read your court's own page. Use the deadline calculator to count days, then confirm with the clerk.

How to file a counterclaim

  1. Step 1: Read the plaintiff's claim

    Note what they say and the amount. Decide what you agree with and what you dispute.

  2. Step 2: Write down your own claim

    List each loss, the date, the amount and the paper that proves it. Keep it to the same dispute.

  3. Step 3: Find the court's counterclaim form

    Check the court's website or ask the clerk. Ask about the fee and the deadline.

  4. Step 4: File it in the same case

    Use the same case number. Keep a copy and proof of when you filed.

  5. Step 5: Let the other side know

    Courts differ on how the plaintiff is notified. Ask the clerk whether you must serve it. See serve court papers.

  6. Step 6: Prepare for the hearing

    Bring copies of your evidence and a one-page calculation. See what to bring.

Check yourself

Before you file a counterclaim

0 of 7 done

Your ticks stay on this device only.

Quick check

Who is the plaintiff in a small claims case where you were sued?

Questions

What is a counterclaim in small claims?

It is your own claim against the person who sued you, filed in the same case. The judge can hear both sides' claims at the same hearing.

Do I have to file a counterclaim?

Not always, but in some states a claim from the same dispute may be lost if you do not raise it now. Ask your law firm and check your court's rules.

What is the deadline to file a counterclaim?

It differs by state and court. Some use a number of days before the hearing and others allow it later. Read your court papers and ask the clerk, and do not wait.

Can my counterclaim be bigger than the original claim?

Possibly, but the court's small claims limit may apply to you too. Some courts move larger counterclaims to another court. Ask the clerk about your state's rule.

Can I just defend myself without a counterclaim?

Yes. You can go to the hearing, explain your side and show proof. A counterclaim is only needed if you want the court to award you money.

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.

File with confidence

Get the code from your law firm and sign up. You decide what to file, and nothing goes to the court without your OK.

No code? FastFile works through law firms. Law firms, talk to us

FastFile is not a law firm and does not give legal advice. FastFile is a self-help platform for people who represent themselves in court. Using FastFile does not create an attorney-client relationship.