If you're sued

Counterclaims and cross-claims: what they are and when they are due

A counterclaim is your own claim against the person suing you. A cross-claim is against someone on your side. Learn the difference and the federal Rule 13 basics.

By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 5 min read

Two sets of papers on a table being compared side by side by a pair of hands, with a pen between them.

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.

The definitions

Counterclaim
A claim by a defendant against the plaintiff, made in the same lawsuit.
Cross-claim
A claim by one party against another party on the same side, such as one defendant against a co-defendant.
Compulsory counterclaim
A counterclaim you generally must bring in this case or lose.
Permissive counterclaim
A counterclaim you may bring here but could also bring in a separate case.

When you are sued, you are the defendant. But the dispute may run both ways: you may think the plaintiff owes you money or broke the same agreement. Instead of filing a separate lawsuit, the rules usually let you bring that claim inside the case you are already in. This article covers the federal approach. State courts have similar ideas with different details.

Compulsory versus permissive counterclaims

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 13(a) says a counterclaim is compulsory if it arises out of the same transaction or occurrence as the plaintiff's claim, and it does not need other parties who cannot be joined. If your claim is compulsory and you do not raise it in your answer, you generally lose the chance to bring it later.

Rule 13(b) says other claims against the plaintiff that are unrelated may be brought too, but you are not required to. These are permissive. You can choose to bring them in this case or sue separately later, though time limits for suing can run while you wait.

Compulsory versus permissive in federal court
Compulsory (Rule 13(a))Permissive (Rule 13(b))
Connection to plaintiff's claimArises from the same events or dealDoes not need any connection
Must you bring it?Generally yes, or it may be lostNo, it is your choice
ExampleYou sued for the unpaid part of a contract; you say they delivered faulty work under that same contractPlaintiff sues over a car sale; you have a separate claim about an unpaid loan

How and when to bring one

In federal court, a counterclaim is stated in your answer, in a separate section after your responses and defenses. It has its own title, its own numbered paragraphs describing the facts, and a request for what you want, such as money damages. Rule 12(a)(1)(B) gives the plaintiff 21 days to answer a counterclaim.

  1. Step 1: Write down your claim

    Say who did what and when, and what harm you suffered.

  2. Step 2: Check the time limit

    Counterclaims have deadlines for suing too. See the statute of limitations guide. Some states let you assert a claim defensively even when the time to sue has passed, but this varies.

  3. Step 3: Put it in your answer

    Add a heading such as Counterclaim after your defenses. See how to write an answer.

  4. Step 4: File and send copies

    File with the court and send a copy to the other side, as you do with any paper. See serving court papers.

If you miss your chance in the answer, Rule 13(f) lets a party ask the court's permission to add an omitted counterclaim, but there is no promise it will be granted. In small claims the rules are different and often simpler. See sued in small claims and small claims counterclaims.

Cross-claims

A cross-claim under Rule 13(g) is against a co-party, for example when two people are sued over the same accident and one says the other is responsible for the damage. It must arise out of the same events as the original case. Cross-claims are optional in federal court. Unlike a compulsory counterclaim, you are generally not forced to bring one now, though doing so can be efficient.

Third-party claims, where a defendant brings in someone new who may owe them, are a separate step under Rule 14 with their own timing. If this might apply to you, ask your law firm or the court's self-help center.

Check yourself

Quick check

You were sued over a contract, and you believe the plaintiff breached that same contract. What is the usual approach in federal court?

Before adding a counterclaim

0 of 6 done

Your ticks stay on this device only.

Questions

Do I have to file a counterclaim?

Only if it is compulsory, meaning it arises from the same events as the plaintiff's claim. Then you generally must bring it in this case or risk losing it. Other claims are optional.

What is the difference between a counterclaim and a defense?

A defense is a reason the plaintiff should not win. A counterclaim is your own claim, asking the court to award you something. You can raise both. See affirmative defenses explained.

Can I bring a counterclaim in small claims?

Often yes, but the rules and deadlines differ by state, and many courts have limits on the amount. Read your notice and check your state's page in the small claims directory.

Does filing a counterclaim cost money?

Some courts charge a fee, and some do not. Fees differ by court, so check the court's website or ask the clerk. If cost is a problem, read about a fee waiver.

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.

File with confidence

Get the code from your law firm and sign up. You decide what to file, and nothing goes to the court without your OK.

No code? FastFile works through law firms. Law firms, talk to us

FastFile is not a law firm and does not give legal advice. FastFile is a self-help platform for people who represent themselves in court. Using FastFile does not create an attorney-client relationship.