How a civil trial works, step by step
Jury or judge, opening statements, witnesses, exhibits, closing arguments and the decision: the usual order of a civil trial, in plain words.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 6 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
The big picture
A civil trial is where a judge or a jury hears both sides' evidence and decides who is right on the issues in dispute. Most civil cases settle or end before trial. If yours does go to trial, knowing the order of events makes it far less intimidating.
This is general information. Courts and judges set their own rules, and small claims trials are usually much simpler and faster than the steps below. Check your court's rules, and for your own case ask your law firm.
Jury or bench trial
| Jury trial | Bench trial | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides the facts | A group of citizens | The judge |
| Who decides the law | The judge | The judge |
| How it starts | Jury selection first | Goes straight to opening statements, if any |
| How you get it | Usually must be asked for on time and may not apply to every kind of claim | Default when no jury is requested |
| Decision | A verdict, announced in court | The judge's ruling, sometimes in writing later |
In federal court, a party who wants a jury must ask in writing within a short time under Rule 38 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, or the right can be lost. Not every claim carries a right to a jury, and many small claims courts do not use juries at all. State rules differ. Check early.
The usual order of a trial
Step 1: Jury selection (jury trials only)
Possible jurors answer questions about themselves. Each side can ask the judge to excuse some of them. The judge then swears in the jury.
Step 2: Opening statements
Each side tells the jury or judge what it expects to show. These are not evidence. They are a roadmap. The person who started the case usually goes first.
Step 3: The first side presents evidence
The person who brought the case calls witnesses and shows exhibits. Each witness is questioned by that side, and then the other side can ask questions.
Step 4: The other side presents evidence
Now the defending side calls its witnesses and offers its exhibits, with the first side questioning them in turn.
Step 5: Rebuttal, if allowed
The first side may be given a chance to answer something new from the other side's evidence.
Step 6: Closing arguments
Each side sums up what the evidence showed and why the judge or jury should decide in its favor. Again, not evidence.
Step 7: Instructions to the jury
In a jury trial the judge explains the law the jury must apply.
Step 8: Deliberation and verdict or decision
The jury goes to a private room to decide, or the judge decides after the closings. In federal civil cases the jury's verdict is generally required to be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise, under Rule 48. State rules differ.
Your part when you represent yourself
Without a lawyer, you do what a lawyer would: give an opening, question witnesses, show exhibits, and close. Judges know this and usually explain the order. Keep things short and stick to facts.
- Opening: two or three sentences on what happened and what you will show.
- Questioning your witness: ask short, open questions such as "What did you see?" and let them answer. See bringing a witness.
- Questioning the other side's witness: ask short questions about the facts you want the judge to hear. Do not argue with them.
- Exhibits: hand a copy to the other side, say what it is and why it matters. See how to present evidence in court.
- Closing: remind the judge or jury of the key facts and what you ask for.
- Objections: wait and answer calmly if the other side objects, and stay respectful if the judge rules against you.
Who has to prove what
- Burden of proof
- The duty to prove a claim. In most civil cases the person who started the case carries it.
- Preponderance of the evidence
- The usual civil standard. It means more likely than not.
- Verdict
- A jury's decision.
- Judgment
- The court's final decision, entered after the verdict or the judge's ruling.
A criminal case needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt, which is a much higher bar than most civil cases. Some civil claims use a higher standard. Ask your law firm what applies in your case.
After the decision
A verdict or ruling is usually followed by a written judgment. Deadlines for asking the court to reconsider or for appealing can be short, and they start running on the date the judgment is entered. Put them on your calendar right away and read the judgment carefully. For what comes next, see our guides on collecting a judgment and on appeals in small claims.
Before trial begins
0 of 6 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Quick check
In an opening statement, what should you do?
Questions
How long does a civil trial take?
It varies from less than an hour in a small claims case to days or weeks in complex cases. The judge may give you time limits, so ask at the pretrial stage.
Do I have a right to a jury?
Sometimes. Whether you can have a jury depends on the type of claim and the court, and you must usually ask on time. Many small claims courts do not use juries. Check your court's rules.
Can I represent myself at trial?
Yes. You have the right to speak for yourself in most courts. You are expected to follow the same rules as everyone else, so preparation matters.
Is an opening statement evidence?
No. Openings and closings explain what each side believes the evidence shows. Only testimony and admitted exhibits count as evidence.
What happens if I lose at trial?
The court enters a judgment. You may have a limited time to ask for a review or to appeal. Read the judgment and note the deadlines right away.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Hearings and trialsPretrial and scheduling conferences explained, with federal Rule 16 basics
A pretrial or scheduling conference is a short meeting with the judge to plan the case. Here is what it is, what gets decided and how to prepare.
6 min readRead
Hearings and trialsHow to present evidence in court when you have no lawyer
The kinds of evidence, how to show them to the judge, how to share them with the other side, and the objections you may hear, in plain words.
6 min readRead
Hearings and trialsHow to bring a witness to court: choosing, preparing and subpoenas
Who makes a good witness, how to prepare them honestly, when a subpoena is needed, and the difference between a written statement and live testimony.
6 min readRead