Federal court or state court: which one is right for your case?
Most cases belong in state court. Some can or must go to federal court. Here is how the two differ and how to tell where yours goes.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 6 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
Two court systems, side by side
The United States has two sets of courts. Each state runs its own state courts. The federal government runs the federal courts. Both can hear civil cases, but they are not interchangeable, and filing in the wrong one can cost you time.
State courts are courts of general jurisdiction. They can hear almost any kind of civil case, including contract disputes, property disputes, family matters and most injury claims. Federal courts are courts of limited jurisdiction. They can only hear the types of cases the Constitution and Congress have given them.
When a case can go to federal court
A federal court generally needs one of two things to hear a civil case.
- Step 1: A federal question. Your claim arises under a federal law, such as a federal civil rights statute, a federal employment law, a patent or copyright law, or the U.S. Constitution. This is called federal question jurisdiction.
- Step 2: Diversity of citizenship. The people or businesses on one side are citizens of different states than everyone on the other side, and the amount at stake is above the minimum Congress set. Both parts must be met. The minimum is set by statute and can change, so read the current figure on the federal courts' website.
Diversity is stricter than it sounds. If you live in the same state as even one person you are suing, diversity usually fails. A business is treated as a citizen of the state where it is incorporated and the state where it has its main place of business.
How the two compare
| Federal court | State court | |
|---|---|---|
| What cases it hears | Only cases the law gives it: federal questions, diversity, and a few others | Almost any civil case, including claims under state law |
| Where rules come from | Federal Rules of Civil Procedure plus each district's local rules | Your state's rules plus the local court's rules |
| Small claims track | None | Most states have one with a dollar limit set by the state |
| Filing fee | Set by federal law; check the court's site | Varies by state and court; check the local site |
| Where records are kept | PACER | The state's own system or the county clerk |
| Who may file without a lawyer | Individuals may represent themselves | Individuals may represent themselves |
Some claims can be brought in either. Many federal civil rights and employment claims, for example, can also be pursued in state court. When a claim could go to either court, there are reasons to pick one, and those reasons depend on your facts. That is a question for your law firm.
How to tell where your case goes
Step 1: Name the law behind your claim
Is your claim based on a federal law or on state law, such as a state contract or property rule? Your law firm can tell you which. If it is only state law, state court is the usual place.
Step 2: Check who is on each side
Write down the state where each person lives and where each business is based. If someone on both sides shares a state, diversity probably fails.
Step 3: Look at the amount
If you are relying on diversity, the amount at stake has to meet the federal minimum. For small amounts, a state small claims court is often the practical choice. See small claims by state.
Step 4: Use the court finder
The which-court tool and the court directory can help you find the right court for your location.
Quick check
You live in Ohio and want to sue a neighbor in Ohio over a fence on a state property claim. Which court fits?
What happens if you file in the wrong court
A federal court that finds it lacks jurisdiction will dismiss the case or send it elsewhere. A case filed in state court can sometimes be moved to federal court by the other side, a step called removal, if the case could have been filed there to begin with. That has its own strict deadlines.
Time limits for filing a claim keep running while a case sits in the wrong court. If you are close to a deadline, do not wait on this question. Ask your law firm soon. The statute of limitations guide explains how those limits work.
Before you decide on a court
0 of 6 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Filing once you know the court
Federal and state courts each have their own forms and filing routes, and they differ court by court. For federal cases, representing yourself in federal court walks through what to expect.
Questions
Is federal court better than state court?
Neither is better in general. They hear different kinds of cases and use different rules. The right one depends on what your claim is based on and who is on each side.
Can I choose federal court for any case?
No. A federal court can only hear a case if it involves a federal law or the parties are from different states and the amount meets the federal minimum. Otherwise it must dismiss.
Is there small claims court in federal court?
No. Federal courts do not have a small claims track. Small claims courts are run by states and local governments, and each sets its own limit.
What does diversity of citizenship mean?
It means everyone on one side of the case is a citizen of a different state from everyone on the other side. A business counts as a citizen of its home states. It is one way to reach federal court.
Can a case start in state court and end up in federal court?
Yes, in some situations. The party being sued can ask to move, or remove, a case to federal court if it could have been filed there. Strict deadlines apply, so act quickly.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Federal court6 min readRead the guideFiling in federal court without a lawyer
PACER and CM/ECF in plain words, how e-filing permission works for people without a lawyer, what a fee waiver is, and why local rules matter.
Federal courtLocal rules and judges' standing orders in federal court: why they matter
On top of the national rules, each federal court has local rules, and many judges have their own standing orders. Here is why they matter and where to find them.
5 min readRead
Federal courtHow to find a federal case number, and what each part means
A federal case number looks like a string of digits and letters, but each part means something. Here is how to read one, where to find yours, and why you need it.
5 min readRead