What evidence to save for a workplace case, and how to keep it lawful
Pay stubs, schedules, texts, emails, reviews and witness names can all matter. Here is what to save, what to leave alone, and how to turn it into a timeline.
By the FastFile teamUpdated Nov 13, 2026 6 min read

General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm. Law firms can contact us about FastFile.
Why evidence matters, even at the start
A complaint tells the court what happened. Evidence is what later shows it. You do not have to attach proof to a complaint, but a judge or jury will eventually ask how you know. Papers and messages from the time of the events carry weight because they were written before anyone was arguing.
Start saving things now, even before you decide to file. Accounts get shut off after a job ends, phones get replaced, and memories fade. Records that exist today may be gone in months.
What to save
| Kind of evidence | What it can show |
|---|---|
| Pay stubs, W-2s, bank deposits | Who your employer is, what you were paid, hours and overtime |
| Schedules and time records | Hours worked, shift cuts, changes after a complaint |
| Texts, chats and emails | What was said and when, instructions, comments, complaints you made |
| Performance reviews and praise | How you were doing before the events, and how that changed |
| Warnings, discipline and termination papers | The reasons the employer gave, and the dates |
| Job description and handbook | Your duties, the employer's own policies and complaint process |
| Medical notes or accommodation requests | A disability, the request, and the employer's response |
| Witness names and contact details | Who saw or heard what happened, or was treated the same way |
| Your EEOC papers | Charge, notices and dates for the court steps |
- Save the original, not only a summary. A screenshot with the date and sender visible is better than a retyped message.
- Back up in two places. Use a cloud folder you control and a drive at home.
- Do not edit or crop in ways that remove context. Keep the original file as well.
Keeping it lawful
Wanting proof does not give you the right to take anything. Some ways of getting it can hurt your case or create new problems for you.
- Do not take confidential company files, such as customer lists, other people's personnel files or trade secrets. Records about your own pay, schedule and treatment are different, and you generally may keep copies of what you were given.
- Do not log in to systems or accounts you are not allowed to use, including a coworker's email.
- Be careful with recordings. Some states allow you to record a conversation you are part of. Others require everyone's consent. Check your state's rule before you record anyone.
- Do not take medical or private information about others.
- Do not delete anything, even things that look bad for you. Deleting records can lead to serious trouble in a case.
- Use your own devices and accounts for your notes and for talking about your case, not your work email or laptop.
Build a timeline
A one-page timeline turns a pile of papers into a story. It also helps you fill in a complaint and see gaps. The federal complaint form asks for dates, and so will anyone who reads your case.
Step 1: List events in date order
Start with when you were hired. Add each event that matters: complaints you made, comments, schedule or pay changes, warnings, the end of the job.
Step 2: Give each line a source
Next to each event, note the paper or message that shows it, such as "text on June 3" or "pay stub for the week of May 12."
Step 3: Add who was there
Write the names of people who saw or heard each event.
Step 4: Mark the legal dates
Add the date of your EEOC charge and of the right-to-sue notice. Use the deadline calculator to see your filing date.
Step 5: Stick to facts
Say what happened, not what you think it means. Keep opinions in a separate note.
Your checklist
Workplace case evidence checklist
0 of 10 doneYour ticks stay on this device only.
Quick check
You find a folder of other employees' pay records on a shared drive you can access. What should you do?
For how to use witnesses later, see subpoenaing a witness. To start your filing plan, see what to do after a right-to-sue letter.
Questions
Do I need to attach evidence to my complaint?
Usually not. A complaint states the facts. You can attach the EEOC notice and, if you wish, the charge. Other evidence is used later in the case. Keep it organized and safe.
Can I record my boss without telling them?
It depends on your state. Some states allow recording a conversation you are part of, and others require everyone's consent. Check before you record, since an unlawful recording can cause problems.
What if the employer already deleted the records?
Tell the court and say what you believe existed. Employers are expected to keep records that matter to a claim, and courts can respond if they do not. Save your own copies.
Can I use texts from my personal phone?
Yes. Messages you sent or received are yours to keep. Take screenshots that show the date and sender, and keep the phone data if you can.
How many witnesses do I need?
There is no set number. Write down every person who saw or heard something, or was treated the same way. You and the documents can also be proof. Ask your law firm what is needed for your case.
General information, not legal advice. Rules differ by court and change over time. For your own case, ask your law firm.
Read next
Workplace casesYou got a right-to-sue letter: what it means and what to do next
A right-to-sue notice means the EEOC is done with your charge and you may now file in court. Here is what it says, the 90-day window, and the steps from notice to filed complaint.
7 min readRead
Workplace casesWorkplace retaliation claims: what counts and how to show the link
Retaliation is punishment for using your rights at work. Learn what protected activity is, what counts as an adverse action, how timing links the two, and what evidence helps.
5 min readRead
Workplace casesUnpaid wages and overtime lawsuit basics under the FLSA
The Fair Labor Standards Act sets minimum wage and overtime rules. You do not need an EEOC step to sue. Here are the time limits, the common problems, and the records that help.
6 min readRead